The Black Friday Marathon: 3 Strategies To Win The Holiday Season without Sacrificing Your Margins

But today's consumer is immune to that playbook. Success is no longer about the biggest offer, but about delivering the most relevant and timely experience. Leaders now recognise that BFCM is not a sprint; it’s a strategic, month-long marathon. Winning isn’t about offering the biggest, most reckless discounts. It’s about running a smarter, more profitable race, where the true prize is not just a sales record, but sustainable, long-term growth.

So, how do you transform your BFCM strategy from a frantic sprint into a profitable marathon? You start by creating a race plan. A successful campaign is not one single event; it’s a three-part strategy that covers the critical phases before, during, and after the sales weekend. It all begins with the most overlooked, yet most crucial, phase: the warm-up.

Strategy 1: The Warm-up—Building Anticipation with Targeted Offers

The most profitable BFCM campaigns are won long before the weekend begins. With a significant portion of holiday revenue now captured in the weeks leading up to the main event, the temptation is to launch a huge, store-wide sale early. But this 'blanket bomb' approach is a direct hit to your profit margins. The smarter play is a strategic warm-up, designed to build anticipation and engage different customer groups with the precise offer they need.

>> Read how to turn customer behaviour into sales

This starts by moving beyond simple, historical segments like 'VIPs'. Your customer file contains distinct groups with different motivations: loyal advocates, price-sensitive deal-hunters, and high-potential browsers. The strategic goal is to create predictive audiences, and this is where an AI engine becomes essential. It can analyse thousands of data points to automatically identify these nuanced groups, allowing you to see which customers genuinely need a deep discount and which will be delighted by a more modest, exclusive offer.

Once you have these intelligent segments, you can build a powerful sense of hype with personalised early access campaigns. By delivering different 'early bird' offers via email and SMS, you create an atmosphere of exclusivity and urgency. This not only encourages high-intent customers to shop early but also ensures your most generous offers are reserved for the segments that will deliver the highest return.

Strategy 2: The Race—Maximising The Value of Every Visit

During the peak traffic surge of the BFCM weekend itself—when global online sales surpassed $74 billion in 2024—your focus must shift from acquisition to maximisation. The strategic challenge is to convert this high volume of discount-seeking traffic into high-value orders. The goal is to turn every discount-driven visit into a journey of product discovery, boosting your Average Order Value (AOV).

While a customer might arrive with the intent to buy a single, discounted item, they are at their moment of highest engagement. This is not the time for a passive checkout; it's the time to actively guide their journey. The key to making this effective at scale is to deploy hyper-relevant product recommendations. An AI-powered engine can analyse a user's real-time browsing behaviour and present personalised cross-sells, like a "Complete the Look" carousel on a fashion site, or upsells that show a premium version of the product they are currently viewing. This does more than just increase basket size; it adds genuine value by making the shopping experience feel more curated and helpful.

Beyond product carousels, this strategy extends to your entire website. With a modern marketing platform, you can deploy dynamic on-site content that adapts to each visitor. This could mean changing the hero banner on your homepage to reflect a returning customer's favourite category, or using a smart pop-up in the cart to offer a small, relevant add-on item. These intelligent nudges are how you turn a €50 discounted purchase into an €85 basket, significantly diluting the impact of the initial discount and protecting your overall profit margin during the most critical sales period of the year.

Strategy 3: The Cool-down—Turning Holiday Shoppers into Lifelong Customers

Here is where the marathon is truly won. The BFCM weekend will bring a massive influx of first-time buyers. For many businesses, a staggering over 80% of these customers will never make a second purchase. The most valuable phase of your strategy is turning these new shoppers into loyal, repeat buyers.

The journey starts immediately after purchase with a flawless, reassuring post-purchase experience. Using your automation platform, you must deliver timely, personalised order confirmations and shipping updates via both email and SMS. This provides the peace of mind that transforms a nervous first-time buyer into a confident one.

Once that trust is established, the real work begins with a "Welcome & Win-Back" journey. The rich behavioural and transactional data you've just collected becomes the fuel for this automated campaign. Your marketing automation platform, powered by its AI, can then send relevant follow-up content, feedback requests, and smart, targeted offers through December and January to secure that crucial second purchase and maximise the true ROI of your BFCM spend.

Conclusion: From A Revenue Guess to A Profit Plan

The strategic shift from a BFCM sprint to a marathon requires a corresponding shift in how you measure success. Instead of focusing solely on the top-line revenue figure, a profitable campaign is managed through a specific set of KPIs that ensure your margins are protected at every stage. Here is a practical guide to the metrics that matter:

First, to ensure your warm-up is surgically precise, your primary KPI must be Conversion Rate by Customer Segment. The goal is not just a high conversion rate, but a high rate from your most loyal segments using your least aggressive offers. By tracking this, you can ensure your best discounts are reserved only for the deal-sensitive shoppers who truly need them, preventing the unnecessary erosion of margin that comes from over-discounting to your entire database.

Second, during the peak race, the key metric for margin recapture is Average Order Value (AOV), specifically for visitors who enter your site via a discounted offer. A rising AOV is direct proof that your on-site recommendation and upselling strategies are working. It shows that you are successfully turning a single-item, low-margin purchase into a larger, more profitable basket, actively rebuilding the profit that was given away on the initial discount.

Finally, the true profitability of your BFCM effort is measured in the cool-down phase. The most critical KPI here is the 60-Day Repurchase Rate for the new customer cohort you acquired over the weekend. This metric tells you if you have successfully turned a high-cost, one-time buyer into a valuable, long-term one. A strong repurchase rate is the ultimate proof that your BFCM spend was a profitable investment in customer lifetime value and not just a one-off cost.

By focusing on this profitability dashboard, you transform your BFCM campaign from a hopeful gamble into a measurable, data-driven strategy. This is how you can confidently navigate the holiday season, knowing you are building a healthier business, not just a bigger sales number.

Visual Summary